How Inflation Affects Home Insurance

How Inflation Affects Home Insurance

inflation spelled out in scrabble

Part 2 of Our Series: Why Does Everything Cost So Much to Insure?

Your house is probably about the same size it was five or ten years ago. It still has the same bedrooms, the same kitchen, and perhaps that bathroom you’ve been meaning to remodel since 2018. So why does it cost so much more to insure? The answer involves more than inflation. Rising construction costs, increasingly sophisticated home technology, labor shortages, and severe weather all contribute to the cost of repairing or rebuilding a home.

In the second installment of our insurance series, we’ll explore why protecting your home and belongings has become more expensive, and what you can do about it.

Your Home’s Value Isn’t Its Replacement Cost

One common misconception about homeowners insurance is that your coverage should match what your house would sell for. Market value reflects what someone might pay for your home and property, including the land and location. Replacement cost estimates what it would take to rebuild the house using comparable materials and construction methods at today’s prices.

The land beneath your home may have considerable market value, but it generally doesn’t need to be rebuilt after a fire or storm. That’s one reason market value and replacement cost can be very different numbers. Even if your home hasn’t changed, rebuilding it could cost substantially more than it did several years ago. Insurance companies aren’t buying your house after a covered disaster; they’re helping pay to put it back together, subject to your policy’s terms and limits.

Building Materials, Labor, and Tariffs

Think about everything involved in building a house. Lumber, shingles, siding, windows, drywall, electrical wiring, plumbing, and heating and cooling equipment all contribute to the final cost. Many construction materials have experienced significant price increases in recent years. Tariffs on certain imported products can add to those costs, while supply-chain disruptions sometimes make replacement materials harder to obtain.

Then there’s labor. Skilled electricians, plumbers, roofers, and carpenters are essential to rebuilding a home, and shortages in some trades can make finding qualified contractors difficult, especially after a major storm. The result is that replacing essentially the same house may cost considerably more than it once did.

When Did Your Refrigerator Become a Computer?

Remember when a refrigerator had a light bulb, a thermostat, and a motor? Today, some refrigerators have touchscreens, cameras, Wi-Fi connections, and sophisticated electronic controls. Your thermostat talks to your phone, your doorbell has a camera, and your HVAC system may contain increasingly complicated electronics.

These innovations offer convenience, but they can also make repairs more expensive. Sometimes a relatively small malfunction requires replacing an entire electronic assembly rather than repairing a single component. This connects to the growing right-to-repair debate, which concerns consumers’ and independent repair shops’ ability to obtain the parts and information needed to fix products.

Of course, homeowners insurance generally doesn’t cover ordinary wear and tear or mechanical breakdowns. Some insurers offer additional equipment-breakdown coverage for certain failures. Apparently, our appliances have gotten smarter. Unfortunately, they haven’t necessarily gotten cheaper to fix.

Mother Nature Isn’t Helping

Ohio homeowners know that thunderstorms, hail, tornadoes, high winds, and falling trees can cause substantial property damage. When severe weather affects an entire community, insurers may face hundreds or thousands of claims simultaneously. Combine that with higher roofing costs, expensive materials, and contractor shortages, and even familiar types of storm damage can generate considerably larger claims.

It’s also important to understand what your policy covers. While standard homeowners insurance commonly covers certain wind and hail damage, flooding generally requires separate insurance.

fall-check-list

Have You Priced Your Stuff Lately?

Now consider everything inside your house. Furniture, televisions, computers, clothing, appliances, tools, kitchen equipment, musical instruments, and all those smaller possessions you’ve accumulated over the years. Imagine replacing everything at 2026 prices. That’s why personal property coverage matters for homeowners and renters alike.

It’s also worth understanding the difference between replacement cost and actual cash value coverage. Replacement cost generally helps pay for comparable new items after a covered loss, while actual cash value accounts for depreciation.

For example, your five-year-old television may still work perfectly, but its depreciated value could be considerably less than what you’d pay for a comparable new one today. That’s an important distinction when reviewing your personal property coverage.

Certain valuables, such as jewelry and collectibles, may have special coverage limits, so reviewing your personal property protection is just as important as reviewing coverage for the house itself.

Is Your Home Still Properly Insured?

Some homeowners policies include automatic inflation adjustments to help coverage keep pace with rebuilding costs, but those adjustments don’t necessarily guarantee adequate protection. Home improvements, renovations, new equipment, and changing construction costs can all affect your insurance needs.

Higher deductibles may help reduce premiums, but they also mean paying more out of pocket when a covered loss occurs. For example, increasing your deductible from $1,000 to $2,500 means accepting an additional $1,500 in potential out-of-pocket expenses when that deductible applies.

That’s why an occasional insurance review makes sense, even when nothing about your home appears to have changed.

Let’s Make Sure Your Coverage Still Fits

At Bill Palmer Insurance, we’ve been helping homeowners, renters, and families throughout Lancaster, Fairfield County, and surrounding Ohio communities understand their insurance needs for nearly 50 years.

If it’s been a while since you’ve reviewed your homeowners or renters insurance, give us a call. We’ll help evaluate your current coverage, discuss what’s changed, and identify potential gaps before they become expensive surprises.

After all, your house may not have gotten any bigger.

But the cost of putting it back together certainly deserves a second look.

Coming up in Part 3: “Your Bumper Has a College Degree”—why modern automobiles have become so expensive to repair and insure.

Special thanks to Markus Winkler for the featured image!